The Archivist
28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC

Status runs societies, and historically that status was concentrated in families protecting their ‘line’. We…

Status runs societies, and historically that status was concentrated in families protecting their ‘line’. We still have dynasties (Murdochs, anyone?), but something in history profoundly weakened them. It’s not what you expect, I will bet. /1 https://t.co/7BBeUT4zoF
Image attached to this post
Post 2 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Many of these family dynasties were maintained by inter-marriage between blood relations. Up to 10% of marriages in the world to this day are between blood relations. What weakened this form of status hierarchy was the Catholic Church, with its campaign against incest. /2
Post 3 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Joseph Heinrich, a Professor of Human Evolutionary Biology, and colleagues, have amassed amazing evidence of the impact of this breaking down of familial lines as the status hierarchies dominating societies. This led to the rise of the now common ‘nuclear family’. /3
Post 4 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Where children are expected to leave the family unit and establish independent families of their own. No historical change is neat, of course we still see significant use of familial lines to create and maintain status. /4
Post 5 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
‘The bank of mum and dad’ is in some ways a returning to that model. We’re heading backwards in history in multiple ways in modern ‘economies’, towards older social forms. That’s what ‘the economy’ remains, a social mechanism to displace modern States. /5
Post 6 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Returning us to older social forms. Monarchy, churches, and the use of status hierarchies more generally to dominate collective life, in a way the public life led by public officials post-WW2 suppressed. /6
Post 7 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Humans as status-loving creatures (nothing drives us more) always actually hated public administration, as the continuous calculation and implementation of a public good. The social model that gave us public health and social welfare. The darling targets of modern politics. /7
Post 8 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
What we call a ‘cost of living’ crisis is really the collapse of the social model of the nuclear family. Also a collapse we see in the epidemic of domestic violence. Many children now live with their parents again, well into adulthood. /8
Post 9 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Will we see a return to inter-marriage, to incestuous family lines in the medieval way? To generate and protect status? There is no necessary direction to history, anything is possible. Many such lines still exist, in watered-down ways. /9
Post 10 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
Societies are 100% social. I’m hoping people can see that the childish, simplified framing of societies using our traditional political categories like Left and Right explains almost nothing at all. Always look for current ways to generate and hoard status. /10
Post 11 of 11 · 28 November 2024 · 18:39 UTC
That’s what society is really all about. The team sports of rival status groups, or status games. Imitative rivalry. Every ‘issue’ you see debated daily is really a battle for status. Information doesn’t run societies. You’re watching rival social groups. /end

← 2024 Threads · ← Back to November 2024