The Archivist
4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC

Reality-based politics is the paradigm shift we need. With Covid, it’s not that we replaced public heath with…

Reality-based politics is the paradigm shift we need. With Covid, it’s not that we replaced public heath with nothing. No society can survive an uncontrolled pandemic. We privatised the public health work. This is fundamental to bypassing the team sports politics of our time. /1 https://t.co/QKEQRoufCS
Image attached to this post
Post 2 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
As I’ve Tweeted before, all of the debates about ‘lockdowns’ argue whether we should have them or not. Because that’s what our different political ‘teams’ support. But lockdowns DIDN’T END, because they can’t end, with a pandemic virus rampant. Without some restriction on…/2
Post 3 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…movement and gatherings, society *stops working* with a pandemic virus in circulation. We never stopped restricting movement and gatherings, we stopped STATES applying these restrictions. That’s the libertarian Oedipus complex. But we then outsourced those restrictions, to…/3
Post 4 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…individuals. Now of course like all privatisations, this meant a job mostly badly done, or not done at all, with little pockets of excellence amongst a sea of dysfunction, and a handful also profiting handsomely from the shift. /4
Post 5 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
For political libertarians, dismantling the State is only ever Step 1. Step 2 is monetising the dismantled services, and redirecting the money to themselves and their buddies. Chumocracy, as some call it. /5 https://t.co/YafYkzZBXh
Post 6 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
We’re not ‘living with the virus’, we’re still running public health measures to try to control infections and illness, because again, a society can’t function unless you do. But those public measures are now private measures, funded and enacted by you and me. /6
Post 7 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
And that’s another critical part of this paradigm shift. Because the political libertarians like us all to think our lives are a binary of individuals and governments. But the largest elephant in the Covid room remains business. Because when public health orders were removed,…/7
Post 8 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…the ‘public health’ work, responsibility for nearly all of our daily encounters with Covid didn’t pass to us, in legal terms. It passed to the workplaces we spend our days inside. To the WHS that has regulated those workplaces for decades. There’s little evidence any…/8
Post 9 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…meaningful WHS work is going on, for Covid, in most workplaces, in flagrant violation of WHS law. But the libertarians will have you believe that our only Covid choices are big government-funded lockdowns, or all of us doing the Covid control individually. Business is again…/9
Post 10 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…privatising the gains and socialising the losses. It gets off scot-free. The same businesses, what gets called an ‘economy’, who pressured for the removal of public health protections, now do almost nothing to fill the gap with their own money. Complete regulatory capture. /10
Post 11 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
We need to completely reject the nonsense idea that not fighting Covid is an option. Again, we’re not living with it, that phrase just means privatising all of the things that need to be done to try to keep society functioning. The physical reality of infectious disease…/11
Post 12 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
…doesn’t allow us to do nothing. Reality-based politics bypasses all of the team sports debating points and returns to these underlying physical realities. Our choice is not governments controlling Covid, or nobody controlling Covid. /12
Post 13 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
It’s us collectively doing and paying for this via our collective public health teams, our elected and non-elected officials. Or us doing and paying for it all ourselves, as individuals. The first option is orders of magnitude cheaper, and actually works. /13
Post 14 of 14 · 4 January 2023 · 19:40 UTC
The second is a con. Only the wealthy and powerful have the means to mount any sort of defence against Covid individually. And they’re too venal and stupid in 2022 to recognise that Covid will eventually smash them as well. We’re already seeing it. /ends https://t.co/RONr91ymeb

← 2023 Threads · ← Back to January 2023